| 2009 Supplementals | (Draft is in reverse order of standings at time of draft. Ties broken as per section 5.5 of the Constitution. |
| % | +/- | # | April | 22 | 23 | June | 25 | 26 | August | 28 | 29 | |
| .297 | -271 | Woody | Len | Kevin | Jim | |||||||
| .347 | -197 | Don | Mike | Mike | Len | |||||||
| .407 | -113 | Len | Doog | Coco | Don | Woody | Woody | |||||
| .424 | -18 | Jamie S. | George | George | George | Dennis W. | Dennis W. | Dennis W. | ||||
| .432 | -81 | George | Barry | |||||||||
| .441 | -45 | Greg | ||||||||||
| .441 | -43 | Mike | Kevin | Rick H. | Rick H. | |||||||
| .483 | -44 | Coco | Mike | |||||||||
| .508 | -78 | Jim C. | ||||||||||
| .517 | 28 | Barry | Woody | Woody | ||||||||
| .534 | 110 | Doog | ||||||||||
| .542 | 58 | Bird | Len | Dennis W. | Len | |||||||
| .551 | -2 | Dennis H. | Jamie | |||||||||
| .551 | 45 | Rick H. | Mike | |||||||||
| .559 | 85 | Jim S. | ||||||||||
| .559 | 143 | John | ||||||||||
| .568 | 81 | Garth | Rick H. | Rick H. | Rick H. | |||||||
| .602 | 77 | Kevin | Jamie | Jamie | Jamie | Len | Len | Mike | Len | Len | Rick H. | |
| .602 | 82 | Hiro | Mike | Mike | ||||||||
| .636 | 183 | Dennis W. | Don | |||||||||
| - | - | Bill | Mike | Mike |